It's Not You, It’s Your Inventory: Why Your Reselling Business Isn’t Making Sales
If you’re spending hours sourcing, listing, and strategizing but still not making the sales you hoped for, you’re probably asking yourself, “What am I doing wrong?” The good news? It’s not you. It’s your inventory.
Let’s break down why your items aren’t selling and how focusing on desirable, competitively priced inventory can transform your reselling business. Whether you’re selling on platforms like Poshmark, eBay, Mercari, or Vestiaire Collective, this guide will show you how to source smarter, sell faster, and flip for profit.
1. Sales Start with What You’re Selling
Reselling is straightforward: if you sell items that people want and price them fairly, they will sell. Yet, many resellers struggle because their inventory isn’t what buyers are looking for.
Fix It: Research what’s in demand. Use tools like Poshmark's "Just Sold" feature, eBay’s completed listings, or Google Trends to identify top-performing categories, brands, and items. Focus on sourcing these pieces to ensure consistent sales.
2. Too Much Strategy Won’t Fix Bad Inventory
While strategies like tiered offers, price drops, and relisting are helpful, they won’t magically make undesired inventory sell. If you constantly rely on these tactics to move items, the issue isn’t your effort—it’s your stock.
Fix It: Audit your inventory. Are your items outdated, low-demand, or priced too high? If so, it’s time to pivot. The key is to sell what buyers are actively searching for—not just what’s available at your local thrift store.
3. Desirable Inventory is Key to Consistent Sales
If you had highly desirable items priced competitively, you wouldn’t need to rely on endless relisting and discounts to make sales. The right inventory practically sells itself.
Fix It: Handpick items that meet these criteria:
- On-Trend: Research current trends and buyer preferences.
- Desirable Brands: Look for brands that consistently perform well in resale markets.
- Competitive Pricing: Check the average resale value and ensure your price is appealing.
4. Stop Relying Solely on Thrift Stores
While thrifting can be fun, it often limits what you can source. Many successful resellers supplement thrifting with targeted online sourcing to find items that are both desirable and profitable.
Fix It: Use platforms like Poshmark, eBay, or wholesale suppliers to source trending, high-value pieces. By intentionally choosing inventory, you’ll improve your sell-through rate and save time.
5. Efficient Sourcing Means Higher Profits
Sourcing strategically doesn’t just save time—it makes your business more efficient. By focusing on desirable inventory that sells quickly, you can work smarter, not harder.
Fix It: Research top-selling items before you source. Platforms like eBay’s Terapeak or Mercari’s trending searches can provide insight into what’s hot in the market. Then, price your finds competitively to attract buyers.
6. You Can Do This, Too
You don’t need thousands of dollars or endless hours to make this work. Start by researching trends and sourcing items with high resale potential. Over time, you’ll see a higher return on investment and spend less time moving items that don’t sell.
Fix It: Commit to improving your sourcing strategy. Invest in tools, track your numbers, and focus on what works. The goal? Make more sales with less effort.
What You’ll Achieve
By shifting your focus to high-demand inventory, you’ll:
- Save time with faster sales.
- Increase profits by avoiding slow-moving stock.
- Build a sustainable, scalable reselling business.
Final Thoughts
If your reselling business feels like a struggle, don’t blame yourself. Instead, take a hard look at your inventory. The truth is, the items you choose to sell are the foundation of your success.
By sourcing smarter, pricing competitively, and focusing on what buyers actually want, you’ll transform your side hustle into a thriving business.
Ready to level up? Start sourcing better and watch your sales soar! But actually, start here...
Are you ready to work smarter, not harder?
Sign up for the FREE More Money, Less Work Masterclass to learn the top three mistakes resellers make and how to fix them.