7 Reselling Mistakes That Are Killing Your Sales (and How to Fix Them)

7 Reselling Mistakes That Are Killing Your Sales (and How to Fix Them)

Not seeing the sales you expected from your reselling side hustle?
You’re not alone — and it’s not that you’re bad at this. You’re just making mistakes that most resellers make when trying to scale on platforms like Poshmark, eBay, Mercari, or Depop.

If you've ever searched “why am I not making sales on Poshmark?” — this is for you.

Let’s break down the 7 most common reseller mistakes and exactly how to fix them.


✅ TL;DR: 7 Reseller Mistakes That Keep You Broke

💻 You’re only listing on one platform — missing massive exposure

💸 You’re underpricing, undervaluing, and overworking

📉 You’re not tracking what’s profitable — or what’s just wasting time

📦 You’re clinging to inventory that won’t move


1. You’re Not Crosslisting Your Items

Each platform has its own audience. Only listing on one = fewer eyeballs = fewer sales.

Fix It:
Use crosslisting tools like Vendoo or List Perfectly to list across eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, and more. More marketplaces = more buyers = faster flips.


2. You’re Selling Items Too Cheap

That $10 sale? After fees, shipping, and time... you made $4/hour.

Fix It:
Focus on inventory that sells for $30+. Use profit calculators before pricing. Source smarter, not cheaper.


3. You’re Not Investing in Your Business

You want $2,000/month results... but won’t spend $100 on tools?

Fix It:
Invest in what saves time or increases accuracy:

Bookkeeping software

Professional lighting

A reseller dashboard (like the one below 👇)


4. You’re Not Valuing Your Time

If it takes 45 minutes to clean, photograph, list, and ship — and it sells for $12 — was it worth it?

Fix It:
Track time spent per item. Let go of low-return efforts. Use tools like Toggl to monitor where your hours go.


5. You’re Holding onto Dead Inventory

If it hasn’t sold after 10 price drops and 3 relists… it’s dead weight.

Fix It:
Bundle it, donate it, or relist with better SEO — but don’t let it sit for 12 months. Track what doesn’t sell so you can source smarter.


6. You Think Returns Are the Enemy

Returns suck — but they’re not personal.

Fix It:
Photograph everything. Describe clearly. Then let it go. Items can be resold. A solid return policy shows you’re legit.


7. You’re Taking Lowball Offers Personally

Low offers are just negotiation starters — not insults.

Fix It:
Counter-offer. Move on. Protect your profit margins without getting emotional. It's just business.


🧠 Bonus Fix: Track What’s Working (and What’s Not)

What brands sell fastest? Which platform makes you the most profit?
If you don’t know, you’re guessing — and that’s costing you.


💡 Real Talk: You Don’t Need to Work Harder. You Need to Track Smarter.

That’s where the GCC Business Dashboard PRO comes in.
This isn’t just a spreadsheet — it’s your command center.

Features include:

🧾 Profit & Loss Calculator

📦 Inventory and Sell-Through Insights

💰 Expense Tracker

🏆 Top Brand & Category Performance

📊 Year-Over-Year Growth Metrics


🚀 Want 2025 to be Your Most Profitable Year Yet?

Stop guessing what’s working.
Start running your reselling business like the scalable operation it is.

👉 Get the GCC Business Dashboard PRO now — and get $25 off


📈 Final Thoughts

Reselling success doesn’t happen by chance.
By avoiding these 7 mistakes — and using data to guide your decisions — you’ll work less, profit more, and build a business that lasts.

✅ Share this with your reseller besties — we’re all trying to make smarter moves this year.

Back to blog

1 comment

Thanks a lot. Schooling that rendered awesome help that put me on a motivational high.

Mamie Simmons

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.